I only caught a bit of The X-Files when it originally aired, usually when my brother-in-law was over, as he loved the series. Recently, though:

  • One of my neighbors was raving about his re-watch of the show
  • I became impressed with Vince Gilligan’s work on Pluribus
  • I read about the upcoming sequel on Hulu
  • Hulu, home of the original series, offered me a free month subscription.

So I used my free month to watch the top 10 episodes of The X-Files, adding five episodes I felt were important to the overall arc of those top episodes.

TitleRankRatingSeasonEpisodeWriter(s)
Pilot#638.211Chris Carter
E.B.E.#448.4117Glen Morgan, et al.
The Erlenmeyer Flask#98.9124Chris Carter
Anasazi#39.1225Chris Carter, David Duchovny
The Blessing Way#278.631Chris Carter
Paper Clip#59.032Chris Carter
Clyde Bruckman’s Final Repose#29.234Darin Morgan
Musings of a Cigarette Smoking Man#49.047Glen Morgan
Small Potatoes#88.9420Vince Gilligan
Gethsemane#258.6424Chris Carter, et al.
Redux#268.651Chris Carter
Redux II#69.052Chris Carter
Bad Blood#19.2512Vince Gilligan
Dreamland#78.964Vince Gilligan
Dreamland II#108.865Vince Gilligan


Weirdly, over the course of the month, the final episode of the original run, “The Truth, Part 2,” jumped from #54 to #1 on IMDB. So I watched “The Truth, Part 1” and “The Truth, Part 2,” which are clearly aimed at devotees of the series, with so many callbacks and references that I was often lost. I toyed with expanding the list to include all the episodes referenced in the finale, but I didn’t think the payoff was worth it. Then, as I finalized the article, the finale reverted back to #54. I advise skipping the final two parter.

Highlights

Wow, the episode “Clyde Bruckman’s Final Repose” (#2) is amazing. Peter Boyle is a fantastic guest star, in fact winning an Emmy for this performance; Darin Morgan won an Emmy for writing this episode. The episode completely stands alone; if you’re going to watch only one episode, make it this one.

If you’re only going to watch three, then I’d add “Bad Blood” (#1) and “Small Potatoes” (#8), both of which stand on their own.

Lowlights

I was disappointed with the writing of Albert Hosteen, a Navajo character in “Anasazi” and other episodes, who was caricatured as a Magical Native American. The episode was set in New Mexico in the story, but filmed in a quarry in Vancouver where they’d painted the rocks red. They then panned out to show Sedona as “New Mexico”:

The truth is out there.

Photo credit: Fox promotional image.